Posts tagged with Hollywood

The Bechdel Test

Does a film contain

  • two named females
  • who talk to each other
  • about something other than a man?
 

This seemingly low bar for female inclusion fails for a surprisingly high fraction of media. Even some excellent films, like The Godfather, fail it.

The Godfather. Can you remember what the actual final shot of the film is? Some people are surprised that the POV is on Kay from inside Michael’s room - her anguished face is blocked out by the closing door. The preceding shot is her looking in as men greet the new godfather. Ultimately the final shot is saying we are with Michael now in that room, and he/we are part of the closing of the door. A great, symbolic final shot. The first of three perfect final shots in the series. A

(You could argue that female exclusion is a theme of The Godfather, but still wouldn’t it have been interesting to view some of the wives’ and daughters’ thoughts to each other about the boys’ mobster behaviour? This isn’t asking for the movie to be about women, just to feature their speech.)

image

The Bechdel test is interesting mathematically because it is a global non-local test. Not every movie needs to pass for “things to be good” but if too many movies fail then things are not good.

Tribar

You could also view the Bechdel test as a vague or smudged boundary condition. Like in sensitivity analysis (in linear programming) where you nudge the boundary planes with a slack vector to see how the system responds. We could perturb the definition of the test, and as we change the criteria or interpretation more or fewer movies will pass. But the test makes its point whether we interpret it loosely or stringently, so we could consider it a suite of boundaries rather than a single, crisp boundary.

Individual playwrights can write whatever they want. Blue Lagoon with two boys? Be my guest. An all-white cast in a story set in rural Sweden circa 1320? Makes sense. Nju Bao (in 炮打双灯) isolated without female counsel in a man’s world? Appropriate. But when the Bechdel test fails en masse something insidious is going on. Which focus group told film investors that audiences hate seeing women talk to each other? Who went through all the scripts and changed all the female names to male ones? I’m guessing no-one.

image

Sexism, racism, and so on are often discussed on a case-by-case basis. Was this or that action sexist|racist|etc on its own? But not every property can be observed at a zoomed-in level. Some properties are only visible at a systemic or macro level.

As a side note, the frequent failure of the Bechdel test also argues, via modus tollens, against a certain kind of “markets will fix things” logic. I would think that economic forces would incent film producers away from being so exclusionary. Aren’t Hollywood executives leaving massive amounts of money on the table by working so assiduously to make sure women are only faces, bodies, and tropes? But yet, count the number of movies that fail this basic inclusivity test. Even though movies are a $X billion industry (therefore locking in a few percent of audience is worth a lot in absolute terms and ∴ worth the time to look at), they still frequently exclude minority perspectives.

Here are some stories that fail the Bechdel test:

  • Bladerunner
    image
  • Red Firecracker Green Firecracker (炮打双灯)
  • Amélie
    image
  • The Graduate
    image
  • King of California
    image
  • The Last Emperor
  • The Godfather
  • The Quiet American [fails for women and for Vietnamese]
  • The Wrestler
    image
  • Dr Strangelove

and here are some that pass the Bechdel test:

  • Star Wars: Clone Wars (both)
    image
  • Firefly
  • Scream
  • Magnolia
    image
  • A Streetcar Named Desire
  • Kill Bill

(por femfreq.tumblr.com)




Video Games by Lana del Rey